Originally Posted by
TonyEarth
For what it's worth, Allen's point of the set up is really important. My first mandolin was a really cheap Rogue (not a recommendation, just an anecdote), with no real set up work at all. It even had a handful issues; by many other's standards a pretty awful instrument. But I absolutely loved it and got a lot of mileage out of it for some years. I can only imagine how much better the experience would have been with a good set up.
If you're willing to spend up to 250, you should by all means do so - I have no real suggestions to give of my own in that range, but it can't hurt to know your budget and spend accordingly. But at the same time, you really can make the most out of whatever instrument you do end up going with, even with a limited budget and choice range.
Even most of my instruments now are not particularly high end, but I love them. Whenever people make sweeping statements about lower-end mandolins as being "unplayable," I smirk with skepticism with the memory of my janky Rogue. That said, there's absolutely value in getting the best bang for your buck and there's a lot of wisdom on the cafe that can help with your decision, so - within your budget, heed the good advice you find, and above all have fun.