-
I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
A few weeks ago I got a REALLY CHEAP soprano ukulele off of Amazon and the Aquila nylon strings for tuning a ukulele in 5ths. I keep this downstairs by my couch, and while watching TV with my wife I’ll practice scales, open chords, double stops, fiddle tunes, and even make an attempt at chop chords. Classic woodshedding.
Other than the chop chords, I have been steadily improving. On the ukulele.
When I go upstairs to my office and grab my mandolin none of the improvement materializes. My fingers are as awkward and my tone is as harsh & amateurish as they ever were.
Has anyone else tried using a tuned in 5ths ukulele as a dummy mandolin, and if so did your “real” mandolin playing suffer?
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
I tried it once but the neck was so wide that I quickly gave up and went back to mandolin.
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
First I will let the "Mean Old Timer" speak and say that picking on a mandolin substitute instrument while watching T.V. is not wood shedding.
Wood shedding really implies, the performer- the mandolin, and tunes and techniques in a somewhat secluded area without much to distract you, in which situations tunes and or techniques are played repeatedly over time until the player can execute them "correctly" with little forethought.
That being said I applaud the effort at trying to keep working on the mandolin while sharing family time.
I have a lot of different size instruments I rotate through and sometimes learning on one will "frustrate" the other, also if If I have a "practice" instrument I try to choose one that is less easy to play (kind of like running with ankle weights)
Sometimes for mastering of a technique comes from:
first -getting some guidance or approval the the physical technique is correct ( challenging sometimes I know)
second - daily repeated exercise then...
put it down, don't play those techniques or tunes or whatever for a day or two
when you pick it back up (most of the time) you immediately take off
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
Just keep the mandolin by the couch :redface:
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Ky Slim
Just keep the mandolin by the couch :redface:
My wife is going away this weekend. She and her friend are going to the Yankee candle factory in Central Massachusetts. They’ll be gone Saturday, overnight, and most of Sunday.
So I totally plan to sit on the couch and play my new mandolin for most of Saturday and Sunday.
Although Strings & Things up in Concord has a used Eastman 815/v for sale. One of the early styles, with the gold tuners. But I plan to drive up there on Saturday and give it a thorough test drive. They’re asking a really attractive price, too, if I knew about that mandolin a day earlier I probably wouldn’t have bought my 514, I probably would’ve bought that one.
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
Bring the 514 along so you can compare the two. Heck, bring the Kentucky too and see if you can do some horse trading if you are smitten with the 815.
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Ky Slim
Just keep the mandolin by the couch :redface:
Jokes aside, mandolins are more physically demanding than ukes. The mandolin is going to "keep you honest" as far as fretting cleanly, picking evenly etc. whereas the uke will be more forgiving. Having a uke tuned to 5ths is fun! Good Luck!
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
Quote:
Originally Posted by
milli857
I tried it once but the neck was so wide that I quickly gave up and went back to mandolin.
Man, now that you say that out loud (Type that out loud?) I think you’re right. I think my fingers got a custom to the wide neck of the ukulele.
Well, this is awful. The only arch top mandolins I know of that have a wide neck are astronomically expensive. I could get a wide neck flat top from big muddy I guess…
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Dan in NH
Man, now that you say that out loud (Type that out loud?) I think you’re right. I think my fingers got a custom to the wide neck of the ukulele.
Well, this is awful. The only arch top mandolins I know of that have a wide neck are astronomically expensive. I could get a wide neck flat top from big muddy I guess…
You could try just going back to playing only mandolin for a while to get used to the narrower neck again, and if it still feels unnatural, you could look at new gear.
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
In a way, I think previously being a guitar player can sometimes be a handicap. As someone who started cold on mandolin, I appreciate the narrower necks because it's easier to fret two courses with one finger, and there seems to be an awful lot of that in chords and doublestops. When I play my mandola, my fingers have to do a *lot* of unaccustomed stretching that would probably be easy peasy for a guitar player.
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
You could just decide to mainly play ukelele? If it seems to be going better for you, I don't see why not.
However, if you really do want to play mandolin, then you probably do need to actually play one, and you most likely will get better.
'Woodshedding' is important. I've been playing mandolin for over 50 years, but if I want to learn a difficult piece, then I do indeed need to put some real effort into it, and that is how I would perceive my woodshedding to be.
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
Practice does not make perfect. Practice makes permanent. Only perfect practice makes perfect.
If you want to get better on mandolin, practice on mandolin.
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
Mandolas have a wider neck. I would much rather play a mandola than a ukulele if those were my options.
As for doing technique drills for mando on the uke, yep, that isn’t optimal or even realistic given the difference feel of the string response. You need another mando for the couch, or get a mandola so you can justify to the wife…it isn’t two of the same things. That translates, time spent on one improves the other.
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
On the topic of woodshedding, I truly did that on guitar 20 years ago, playing ten hours a day for two years, with topics to study and technique exercises etc. Honestly, at the end of it I was a more skilled guitar technician with better understanding of what to play and why; however I was a worse musician. For years I let those acquired skills dictate what I played and I tainted my inner voice too much. Everything became too “impressive” and ego driven…had to use all the tools I acquired. It took years to learn to forget what I knew and just play the right damn note. Glad I did it because overall I am now in a better place, but i don’t know if I would take that path again. Learning at a school, sur, because you are constantly communicating with your instrument, but woodshedding is a sole pursuit with specific intent. .
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Sue Rieter
In a way, I think previously being a guitar player can sometimes be a handicap. As someone who started cold on mandolin, I appreciate the narrower necks because it's easier to fret two courses with one finger, and there seems to be an awful lot of that in chords and doublestops. When I play my mandola, my fingers have to do a *lot* of unaccustomed stretching that would probably be easy peasy for a guitar player.
I think in some cases previously being a guitar player can lead to new mandolin players thinking they need a mandolin with a wider neck, possibly because they're expecting fluency on the guitar to translate to fluency on mandolin. I had 20+ years behind me as a guitar player by the time I picked the mandolin up and from the get go I treated it as if I was a novice period full stop, learning the left hand mechanics needed to fret cleanly and move comfortably around the smaller mandolin neck rather than viewing it as cramped etc., so my guitar background was never a detriment to my mandolin progress.
As others have pointed out to Dan, his version of "woodshedding" hasn't made him worse, it's just a case that he's expecting like for like performance when he transfers the mechanics he's engrained on the ukulele to his mandolin and given the different neck sizes, nylon vs. steel strings and different string tension that's a big ask.
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Jill McAuley
As others have pointed out to Dan, his version of "woodshedding" hasn't made him worse, it's just a case that he's expecting like for like performance when he transfers the mechanics he's engrained on the ukulele to his mandolin and given the different neck sizes, nylon vs. steel strings and different string tension that's a big ask.
I experience this when I learn a tune on mandolin and then attempt to play it at full speed on tenor banjo. The notes are all in the same places, but my fingers have to adjust to the new fingering, single strings, wider frets, picking technique etc …
I have to relearn how to play the song on each different instrument because, well, they are different!
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Mando Esq
I experience this when I learn a tune on mandolin and then attempt to play it at full speed on tenor banjo. The notes are all in the same places, but my fingers have to adjust to the new fingering, single strings, wider frets, picking technique etc …
I have to relearn how to play the song on each different instrument because, well, they are different!
For me, even going from one mandolin to a different one takes some adjustment.
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
Quote:
Originally Posted by
tmsweeney
I have a lot of different size instruments I rotate through and sometimes learning on one will "frustrate" the other, also if If I have a "practice" instrument I try to choose one that is less easy to play (kind of like running with ankle weights
Yes to this. My first mando was a GC “Mitchell” received as a gift. Heavy strings and not the easiest player. I’ve used it as a traveler and when settling back into my other instruments my efforts were worthwhile.
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
If you are serious about improving your mandolin playing, it might be a good idea to hire a private instructor with a very good reputation/references. Of course, you might have already tried doing that. And, has your mandolin been set up by a pro luthier who has a lot of experience with mandolin setup, specifically? Also, what picks are you using? Some picks can get quite a strident tone on mandolin, especially if one's pick technique is not correct.
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Dan in NH
My wife is going away this weekend. She and her friend are going to the Yankee candle factory in Central Massachusetts. They’ll be gone Saturday, overnight, and most of Sunday.
So I totally plan to sit on the couch and play my new mandolin for most of Saturday and Sunday.
Although Strings & Things up in Concord has a used Eastman 815/v for sale. One of the early styles, with the gold tuners. But I plan to drive up there on Saturday and give it a thorough test drive. They’re asking a really attractive price, too, if I knew about that mandolin a day earlier I probably wouldn’t have bought my 514, I probably would’ve bought that one.
Uh-oh… when the wife is away, the husband will play… and buy another mandolin. Maybe she will come home with $1500 worth of candles? :)
Sounds though that you got a nice new mandolin to get acquainted with. I would play that one as much as possible and see what you can get out of it. Down the road you may very well prefer a wider neck mandolin but you have to give this one a chance. After all you just got it.
I know, I should talk with a big closet full of mandolins. But the downside of MAS is that it gets in the way of actually playing sometimes. Then again, I much prefer them to candles.
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
I wonder if the issue isn't so much musical or practical as it is social. You said you play/practice on the ukulele while sitting on the couch with your wife while watching TV. I wonder whether these peripheral sensory stimuli distract your mind enough that you are paying less attention to your playing with your conscious mind, and are operating on a more intuitive level. Sometimes overthinking what one is doing can be detrimental to the success of the operation. Am I correct in assuming you are using the ukulele in this context because it is quieter and less distracting for your wife? Perhaps bringing the mandolin into this situation will help your progress. If she's willing to tolerate your doing this, of course. If it would take too much thought and effort to play the mandolin there more quietly, that might be too distracting for you. Perhaps compensating for the increased volume of the instrument by increasing the volume of the TV would work. I dunno, just spitballing here. It's been a long time since I played mandolin while watching TV. I found it too distracting, for both activities. ;) YMMV, of course.
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
You gotta practice how you will play. Elsewise you're expecting muscle memory on one unique board to translate to another with twice the different strings.
Jamie
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
There is so much more to mandolinning well beyond getting the fingerings right. Especially, you mentioned tone. I don't think one can develop good tone on a mandolin by practicing something else.
That said, I did experience gigantic leaps in progress on my mandolin playing when I took up the fiddle. Never got anywhere useful on fiddle, but my conception of the mandolin fretboard was revolutionized.
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
I have various tenor instruments (guitar, banjo, tenor Vega "lute"); I have guitars (electric and acoustic); I have mandocellos, a mandola, an octave mandolin, varied vintage bowlback mandos (Italian and American and Italian-American), vintage Gibson mandos (F4s and an A4), a German piccolo mandolin, and, need it be said?, banjo mandolins. On these various instruments are strings in the entire range from tried & true J74s to the lightest Savaras and Aquilas I could find, made in various combinations of wound metal to nylgut and nylon. I play with Blue Chips, Dunlops, Apollos, Golden Gates, Red Bears Gallis, Wolle, and many unbranded picks made from, well, you-name-it, and thickness ranging from the flakey Dunlop .38mm to the 4.2mm Dunlop flow, and in sizes and shapes from the petite Pettines to the unwieldy romans. One of my greatest daily pleasures is, in decent Borg fashion, adapting.
That said, I perform only for my dog (now sadly I must use a singular noun here) who enjoys fiddle tunes from here, there, and everywhere, golden-age compositions, and as much Bach as I can force him to tolerate. Therefore, Koukou's ears aside, there is no reason for me to perfect anything. And I don't. But ... ain't life grand!
-
Re: I’m afraid woodshedding has made me worse
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Dan in NH
Man, now that you say that out loud (Type that out loud?) I think you’re right. I think my fingers got a custom to the wide neck of the ukulele.
Well, this is awful. The only arch top mandolins I know of that have a wide neck are astronomically expensive. I could get a wide neck flat top from big muddy I guess…
"Wide" is relative. A wide-neck mandolin typically has a 1-3/16" nut - which compared to a uke is probably still quite narrow.
In comparison, your 514 has a 1-3/32" nut, and your kentucky 250 likely is at 1-1/8".
When I bought my Eastman 515V, I was concerned that the 1-3/32" nut would be hard to play, as all my prior playing experience was on instruments with 1-1/8" widths. I actually find that I like the narrower size of the Eastman - it makes fingering the 2200 A chord with one finger much easier.
Hope you enjoy the 514. I did peek at the 815V on the strings and things web site - that is a really good price.