I have used flat wound strings on many instruments but never a mandolin. Anyone have some experience with them? I have always used the TI strings but they cost a bunch. I have seen the half flat ones, Are they somewhat comparable?
Printable View
I have used flat wound strings on many instruments but never a mandolin. Anyone have some experience with them? I have always used the TI strings but they cost a bunch. I have seen the half flat ones, Are they somewhat comparable?
I’ve used TI flat wound and D’ADDARIO flat tops in the past….of the two I prefer the flat tops. The flat wounds took off to much overtones from my mandolin, the flat tops are very comfortable, and gives a great tone for my bluegrass mandolining.Quote:
Originally Posted by peterbright
Full disclosure, I use GHS Americanas as my preferred string.
look at these:
http://emando.com/shop/strings8_flatwound.htm
I'm experimenting with the mandola flatwounds now.
You give up the roundwound sound for sure, but you get a lot of other things.
The jury is out on this for me.
I love the TI but I did have to change the pick I use to brighten them up just a touch.
I really love the Thomastik Infeld mediums on my Eastman 515. Great sound, easy to play, worth the price.
I have used TI mediums on my mandolin, mandola, and mandocello for many, many years.
I use starks it seems they are still less tension than the medium EJ74 set and even lighter than the EJ75.
I use the half-flat ones, D'Addario makes FlatTops which are basically round wound strings that are ground flat. I've used them for about 10 years now and like them a lot, once they're broken in (less brightness than round-wound phosphor-bronze strings).Quote:
Originally Posted by peterbright
TI's are on my list of "maybe someday" strings, but honestly I'm pretty happy with the FlatTops and will probably stick with them.
Note: D'A FlatTops come with a very fine (.015) wound 2nd course, and with the amount of playing I do the winding wears through in about a week. I routinely replace them with a plain string.
D'Addario has their EFW -74 string
That's my favoriteQuote:
Originally Posted by mandroid
That makes sense, I was baffled by your thread about sets lasting 7years…I enjoyed flattops, but blew through the wound a.Quote:
Originally Posted by dhergert
Almost a year ago I bit the bullet and got two sets of TI flats for a newly acquired Collings MTO. Must say they are exquisitely made. I was amazed to realize that the A was such a fine-wrappedcomposite, not a plain steel. The feel is great.
11 months after installing the first set, I am still using it. Not breaking any strings in 11 months is a record for me. Of course my pub-band has been inactive and the usual round of devil-take-the-hindmost-tempo sessions has not been available. Still, pretty amazing.
My only problem is that I have been reluctant to get to the second set, with no broken ones, because I am so damn cheap it just goes against the grain to change them while they are all intact, although sonically I’m sure it will be an improvement. But they have been very consistent.
I can see getting a couple of sets a year, but not for all my instruments, just the best—the others will have to make do with D’addario flats or good ol’ J74s.
Going on 2.5 years with mine and I don’t notice any real lose in tone. Sounds great. So considering a big monthly string change I’m at about the same monthly cost as cheaper strings would run. And I know guys who change string more often that that!
I own a Collings MT2-O that I bought used in 2018 that came with a set of D’Addario rounds on it. The D’Addario’s were tiny and harsh sounding and shortly after I got it I changed to the Thomastik-Infeld flats. The TI’s smoothed out the top end and my wife made multiple comments on how much better it sounded with the string change so I’ve been using them on it ever since. They’re expensive for mandolin strings but when comparing them to my wife’s cello strings they’re cheep.
Agreed, they are the best.
Have TI Mittel on my Peter Coombe. Really enjoy the tone and they are very easy to play. Have tried both TI and D'Addario FW in the past. I find the TI softer feeling, and with just maybe a hair less volume, but they last forever. On this instrument, volume is still really good. Eventually will probably try both the D'Addario FW and then TI Stark. But am in no rush to do that.
FWIW, tried the D'Addario FW on my Gibson A Jr. when I first got it and didn't like it at all. And I did write up at one point that the TI Starks were good on my Collings MT. Unfortunately, the larger band I'm in couldn't hear it as well. So they didn't last.
I have developed a strong preference for the Flat Tops EFT-74 on my F holed mandolins (F-12 and A-5L) and Flat Wound EFW-74 on my oval hole (teens F-4). I have tried the TI mittels and starks on the F-4 but didn't like the muffled thuddyness of the sound and the bigger hit to my wallet. The EFW-74s are expensive compared to other D'Addario string pricing but are a bargain at only 1/3 of TI prices, and achieve nearly the same sound and feel of the TIs. Bravo D'Addario!!
Len B.
Clearwater, FL
I use Fisoma Supersolo flatwounds. Here in Germany they are about half the price of Thomastiks (which I used to use until they became so insanely expensive). I would recommend them, but don't know how easily available they are in the USA.
Not to mention "Fisoma Supersolo" might be the most badass name for a mandolin string! That's the kind of name 10-year-old me would come up with for his mandolin strings :))Quote:
Originally Posted by Polecat
I do not find Thomastik Infeld too costly, but I am from the violin world. A good set of violin strings, such as Dominants, also from Thomastik Infeld, were selling at $73 when I called my local violin shop today. That is for a single G, a single D, a single A and a single E. A lot of pros play with Dominants. My preferred quality strings are over $100 for a set of four violin strings. However, I believe you really can get cleaner, purer sound from more expensive violin strings if you select carefully. I aspire for the same clarity of voice on the mandolin and, so far, the Thomastik Infeld M154, work well for me. And I get eight strings for much less than 4 for the violin.
Of course, I am still a bit of a mandolin neophyte and will keep hunting for the perfect strings and seeking the advice of those more experienced.
I hope you find your dream strings...
My new Northfield is being shipped with the Dadderio flats and I ordered some TI's to try next.