Case cosmetic repair question

[Hokey Pokey]

Question for the group:

I have a 1916 Gibson A1 in pretty nice shape. The case is fully functional but beat-up on the outside. Should I try to make the case look better (shoe polish, vinyl spray etc.) or will this just lower the value of an good vintage instrument. I don't gig much and mainly use the mandolin at home.

Any thoughts,

HP

[Ray(T)]

Unless any improvements you make leave the case looking entirely original, I would leave it well alone. Cases, with vintage instruments, are generally sold as a "sweetener" - i.e. "Includes original case".

Incidentally, repairs to "working" instrument cases are usually done using Gaffer Tape.

[Loudloar]

I mostly agree with Ray(T). Replacing a broken handle or hinge with vintage style parts or regluing seams that are coming apart shouldn't decrease the value. But doing a major "Facelift" is like refinishing your A1 with a shiny nitro sunburst finish. Honest wear and character are expected and much more valued than a "restoration" that removes originality.

In general I'm against using tape to repair a case. Duct tape is horrible and is impossible to remove later. Gaffers tape has a less nasty adhesive but the tape is not as resistant to abrasion.

My two cents.
Steve

http://www.stevekirtley.org/vintagecases.htm
https://www.facebook.com/groups/vint...strumentcases/