Seeking Advice: Seller Misrepresented Condition.

[slimt]

What was the price paid? Also did you ask questions in regards to condition prior to purchase?

[allenhopkins]

IMHO you made a wise decision to keep a great-sounding though "distressed" mandolin at an excellent price.

Also IMHO, the seller was a bit weasel-y; if he considered the Flatiron "unblemished" he has a much different definition of the term, than most of us.

Good luck with it!

[David L]

What was the price paid?

A gentleman doesn't ask.

[Mark Wilson]

I would be more disappointed if it showed up pristine and sounded meh. You were right to get some kickback - it will effect resale.
For me - if it sounds and plays nice - finish cracks are not a deal breaker like tone. Similar to moderate to heavy use wear. If its a a good sounding mandolin you won't stay disappointed long. I like that my mandolins (save one) are festival friendly while looking nice still.

Meanwhile maybe post a NMD full picture. Cheers