Re: Octave Mandolin question: Teardrop versus mando-guitar?
As mentioned above, it might be worth exploring F-body octaves and the arched top and back "cello-influenced" ones as well. Including these additional shapes could significantly expand the conversation beyond the original "A vs guitar-body" scope. I know the OP is primarily interested in those two but in case there's any chance of some of these other possibilities it can be a great corner of the world of musical instruments to explore.
I mention this because speaking for myself, I generally prefer the larger-bodied archtop OMs (in the F- and arch-bodies) over the A- or flat-top guitar shapes. Of course many of those are great too so this isn't a blanket statement, just a suggestion it might be worth considering the F- and arch-bodies too.
Best luck on your journey!
Gavin Baird F4 & F5, Weber Octar, Gibson K-1, Guild D50, Martin D35, Yairi DY-84, etc...
Bookmarks