Re: The Swan played by Ranieri on an Embergher
"Something we wouldn't do today...." (comment in the video about descending glissando).
I was a grad student in the days when performance practice and period instruments were all the rage. The emphasis then was, and still is, on a lighter, crisper, un-romanticized sound in pre-19th century music. No vibrato in 16th Century a cappella, less legato in baroque articulation, phrasing as rhetoric rather than emotional expression...
Here we have the same idea applied, historically informed, but with the very romanticized approach. Initially the playing, although beautifully smooth and rich, struck me as a bit too sentimental. But I realize that is probably, as Ralf explains, just what Saint Saens wanted. I have heard baroque and even Renaissance music performed this way, ruining (I think) the purity and spirit of the music. But here, I have to adjust my ears and say yes, that buttery, fluid phrasing fits the music.
Hmmmm... The Swan....I think I better go practice tremolo more on my mandocello. Something I better do today.
Thank you Maestro!
Jim
Dr James S Imhoff
Boston University
Oregon Mandolin Orchestra
1912 Gibson K4 Mandocello; Thomann Mandocello; Stiver F5; American? Bowlback; Martin 00016; Dusepo Cittern/liuto cantabile
Bookmarks