As usual I would side with Jim here. The serial number of the asymmetrical one is puzzling, since the earliest asymmetrical Style A I have listed is somewhere near the 1,000 serial number range. Is the 1912 indication written on the label, or just an estimate from the dealer of the instrument's year of manufacture?
The clue here is the 'SPCL' indication on the label - it must have been a custom order. I have seen the 'Special' indication only once before I think on a L&H flatback mandolin label, and that very likely seemed to be a one-off as well, as it was not a catalog model.
Your #49 was likely made in 1917, when Style A was introduced. The tailpiece with the 1919 indication can't be original to that mandolin, but put on later as a replacement of the original (certainly not the first time this happened to these instruments).
If you want to go the period correct route (for both instruments), just swap out both tailpieces and voila!
By the way - I think I've explained to Jim that there were still a number of uncleared issues regarding the 100 or so Style A-C mandos that I have data on. Please don't consider the Washburn book as the final word on these fine instruments - maybe Jim can write that book!
Bookmarks